Wow, this has been a long time coming!!! I took this photo this afternoon from the same vantage point as this photo from the Zillow listing.

This room has actually undergone way less renovations than every other room in the house. Mostly what has been tricky about it for me is the furniture placement--it's a very long room with a picture window at one end, a fireplace 1/3 of the way along one wall, the wall opposite the fireplace is open to other rooms, and the end opposite the picture window has French doors leading to the sunroom. It's too big to arrange furniture in a single conversational grouping, but not quite big enough to function entirely as two separate rooms. Here's another couple of listing photos that shows how the previous owners broke it up...


And here is the very first photo I ever took in this house--we moved in on October 27th and I took this shot of Neil after we got home from trick-or-treating on Halloween.

The first month that we lived here, I didn't do anything renovation-wise other than painting all of the trim white around the big picture window. Mostly I was just busy ordering furniture. ;-) I knew I wanted two big chesterfields, and then Isaac and I had one very fun afternoon at West Elm buying pillows and rugs and throws. So my initial layout had one chesterfield in front of the window, and the other facing it about six feet away. In this photo, you can see the unpainted trim + the old curtain rods (really wish I had a good picture of those, as they had enormous finials that led Neil to nickname them "the staff of the Mushroom King"). The curtains were in the living room in our previous house, and I replaced them pretty quickly as well. (The first three months that we lived here I spent SO MUCH MONEY on furniture/decor...we were still rocking the same couches we'd purchased before our wedding, so we were loooong overdue to replace basically everything.)

Here's that same view this afternoon, minus the cute little Abigail.

So mostly this room looked the same for the first year or so that we lived here. I kept moving things around because I could not get the right furniture arrangement...it was fine for Christmas because we all wanted to hang out by the tree, but the rest of the time it felt like the couches were shutting off the fireplace part of the room.

Cute little Matty...oh man I miss his fluffy hair!

And one more because I have been so terrible about blogging and I don't think I ever posted this...so here is Christmas 2017.

We did a ton of other projects over the next few months (repainted the entire basement, built cabinets in the laundry room + redid closets downstairs, redid the upstairs hall bathroom and the downstairs bathroom just off the laundry room, and repainted the dining room). Then we went on vacation and when we came back I literally took a hammer to the built-ins on August 5 (2018) on either side of the fireplace one night because I just hated them SO much and did not want to look at them for one more second. Neil was very very skeptical and so I just stood there doing it by myself while he was like "I think you're going to regret this" but I KNEW they had to go. (When it got to the lift-the-heavy-cabinet-out part he started helping.)


There was a ton of wiring back there so the drywall looked terrible & the carpet was missing underneath the built-ins, but I still thought it was an enormous improvement!

A week later Neil hung new drywall & taped and mudded everything...

And then I started on the next part of my vision which involved whacking out all the straight-line mortar that was left (straight line because of the built-ins going right up to the fireplace whereas I wanted a more organic look). This made an ENORMOUS mess and was very very time-consuming.

Here's the straight line version...I just did not love it.


So after I chipped out all the mortar I had a lot of giant cracks and holes, so I used refractory mortar to patch everything up. This also made a giant mess and took forever.

Then I waited for Doubting Neil to go out of town and started painting. Fortunately he is not unused to finding all kinds of DIY surprises when he gets home. I was super happy with how this turned out--basically I mixed latex and acrylic paints with water until I was happy with the consistency and color, painted it on, wiped it off, etc. I used probably 3-4 different shades and then would go back over the lighter shades with darker splotches and vice versa--my goal was to not have it look like painted stone but to look like it was the actual stone's original color. And somewhere in there I painted the walls to match the original shade (except then I spattered them with gray paint from the fireplace, so oh well...I'm planning to repaint the living room this fall anyway).

And here is what it looks like today.

We left the fireplace mantel-less for three months or so...I really loved the clean-lined minimal look of no mantel, but then as soon as we started getting out Christmas decorations I was like no way must have a mantel. In this time gap we also completely redid our kitchen (I was painting cabinets for a month straight!), Neil had a million work trips to very interesting places, and everyone did fall sports and it was CRAZY TOWN.
So eventually Neil built this one out of pine (I wanted it to look like it was just one giant barnwood beam). It was actually a super complicated process that involved a lot of engineering and jigsaw skills so that it would look like a single piece whereas in actuality it couldn't be solid because of the weight, plus it needed to be cut just right to accomodate every individual stone so that the mantel would fit snugly with no gaps. We hung it on December 2...just in time for stockings!
I can't remember what color I stained this, but I do remember how delightfully fun it was to whack it with a chain and a bag of screws while I was distressing it to make it look more like barn wood.


And ta-da! Christmas 2018. As I said at the beginning of this post, this was BY FAR the most minimal changes we've done to any room, so it seemed like a good one to start the ball rolling...
A few more pics from today (still working on the furniture layout, but this seems to work best so far). The main issue I have with this room is that it has very little natural light and only has 4 can lights in the ceiling, so it always feels super dark to me unless I walk around turning on all the lights. So naturally we gravitate to spending more time in the family room...so my goal is to figure out the lighting issue and make this a room where we spend more time as a family.
Someone gave us a free piano five or six years ago and I still haven't replaced it...yikes! My plan is a baby grand because I think it would be gorgeous in front of that window, but there are so many other things to spend money on...so my stop-gap solution was refinishing the piano face earlier this summer. I'm happy with how it turned out (and one of these days I reallllly need to replace the mismatched bench).
This little zone here almost invariably has a kid curled up with a book...these two bookcases are dedicated to picture books (and my half-finished paintings).
And a sun room sneak peek to take us out!













